Last week Google released a final version of
Google Maps for Windows Mobile Phones. You can download the CAB directly to your Windows Mobile phone via this
link.
I have been using
Microsoft's Mobile Live Search (BETA) for a while now. I love the app and it has been very handy for tracking down the nearest In-n-Out burger joint while on
business trips. I wanted to see how Google Maps Mobile stacks up against Microsoft Mobile Live Search. I downloaded and installed it on my phone yesterday. It is very small in size, 607 k, and installs quickly.
They both offer the same basic features; traffic information, directions, location via GPS, map and
satellite views, and a "search nearby" feature to locate businesses (which I use all the time) near a selected location. I would recommend a phone with 3G while using both apps.
Microsoft Mobile Live Search (BETA)
MLS's UI is more polished that Google Maps.
MLS search nearby feature turned up more pizza places near my house that Google Maps did. Also once a business is located, using the search nearby feature, for me it's easier to call the business with
MLS than Google Maps. It is worth noting that it take the same about of key strokes (2) for each,
MLS key strokes seem easier. With
MLS you set the city you would like to search within unlike Google Maps where I almost always need to type my city while searching for a location.
MLS allows you to save map data to your storage card which is an important feature for me. They really don't include a lot of storage on Windows Mobile phones and every MB counts. I was unable to find this feature with Google Maps. While getting directions,
MLB will show you complete list step by step directions without the need for the map which is handy. Google Maps requires the map and does not have a turn by turn listing.
Google Maps Mobile
Google Maps loads in 1/4 the time of
MLS and map navigation/loads are also much faster. This is a huge plus for me (sometimes navigating on the map in
MLS is painfully slow). Google Maps has a cool feature which allow you to find a location by using a address or phone number of a contact stored on your phone (from the map click Menu, Options,
Lookup Contact). Map turn by turn directions are easier to use on Google Maps than
MLS. Once you plot a course in Google Maps you just enter 3 for the next turn and 1 to go back to the previous. With
MLS you need to select Menu and then Next Turn which is a bit more cumbersome.
I am sure I will find more differences the more I get to play with Google Maps. As for now I think the speed of Google Maps makes it a winner (but not by much). I am interested to see where Microsoft will take Mobile Live Search once it's out of beta.